Skip to content
Rubric Financial

Tax Strategies

Roth Conversions: When Paying Tax Now Lowers Your Lifetime Tax Bill

How a Roth conversion is taxed, when it makes sense, how to size it to a bracket, and the hidden costs: IRMAA, NIIT, the senior deduction, and the SALT phase-down.

By 8 min readPublished

A Roth conversion is a voluntary tax bill. You move money from a traditional IRA or 401(k) into a Roth account, pay ordinary income tax on it now, and in exchange the money and all of its future growth come out tax-free, with no required distributions during your lifetime.

Whether that trade is worth it depends almost entirely on one comparison: the tax rate you pay on the conversion today against the rate the money would face if it stayed put. Done in the right years, in the right amounts, conversions can lower a household's lifetime tax bill substantially. Done carelessly, they pull income into a high bracket, trigger surcharges that never showed up on the tax return, and cannot be undone.

This guide covers how conversions are taxed, when they tend to work, how to size them, and the costs that hide outside the bracket table. For the mechanics of how each account type is taxed, see tax-deferred, tax-free, and taxable accounts.

How a conversion is taxed

The pre-tax amount converted is added to ordinary income in the year of the conversion. There is no 10% early-withdrawal penalty on the conversion itself, at any age. There is no income limit, and there is no annual cap.

After-tax basis and the pro-rata rule. If you have made nondeductible traditional IRA contributions, that basis converts tax-free. But the IRS does not let you pick which dollars convert. The taxable share is based on your total pre-tax and after-tax balances across all traditional, SEP, and SIMPLE IRAs at the end of the year. Someone with $7,500 of basis and $92,500 of pre-tax IRA money who converts $7,500 pays tax on 92.5% of it. Balances in a 401(k) are not counted, which is why rolling pre-tax IRA money into an employer plan is a common first step before a backdoor Roth.

No do-overs. Recharacterizing a conversion back to traditional has been prohibited since 2018. Once the conversion is done, the tax is owed.

Paying the tax. Conversions work best when the tax is paid from money outside the retirement account. Withholding the tax from the conversion itself shrinks the amount that reaches the Roth and, if you are under 59½, the withheld amount is a distribution subject to the 10% penalty.

Estimated taxes. A large conversion can create an underpayment penalty if withholding and estimates do not keep up. A conversion late in the year can be covered by increasing withholding from wages or IRA distributions, which the IRS treats as paid evenly through the year.

When conversions tend to work

The core test is today's marginal rate versus the future rate on the same dollars. The future rate is the harder number. It includes:

  • Your own future bracket, once Social Security, pensions, and required minimum distributions stack on top of each other.
  • Your surviving spouse's bracket. After one spouse dies, the survivor generally files as single, with roughly half the bracket width on similar income.
  • Your heirs' brackets. Most non-spouse beneficiaries must empty inherited traditional accounts within ten years, often during their peak earning years. Inherited Roth accounts come out tax-free. See inherited IRAs and the 10-year rule.
  • Future tax law, which no one knows.

Situations where today's rate is often lower than the future rate:

The gap years. Between retirement and the start of Social Security and RMDs, many households have unusually low taxable income for several years. These are the classic conversion years.

Business loss or low-profit years. A startup year, a year with large depreciation from a cost segregation study or equipment purchase, or a down year for the business can leave room in the low brackets. Converting fills that room. A net operating loss or excess deductions that would otherwise be wasted can be absorbed by conversion income.

Large future RMDs. A traditional balance large enough that RMDs at 73 or 75 will push you into higher brackets than you are in now is a strong signal.

Moving to a higher-tax state, or away from one. Converting before moving to a high-tax state, or after moving to a no-tax state, captures the state rate difference as well.

Situations where conversions often do not work: you are in a high bracket now and expect a lower one later; you would have to pay the tax from the converted funds; you expect to need the money within five years; or you intend to leave the traditional account to charity, which pays no income tax on it at all.

Sizing a conversion: fill the bracket, then stop

Conversions rarely need to be all-or-nothing. The usual approach is a partial conversion each year sized to fill the current bracket, or a target bracket, without spilling into the next.

For a married couple filing jointly in 2026, taxable income up to $211,400 stays within the 22% bracket, and up to $403,550 within the 24% bracket. If projected taxable income for the year is $150,000, a conversion of about $61,400 fills the 22% bracket exactly. Converting $100,000 would put the last $38,600 in the 24% bracket, which may still be worthwhile, but is a deliberate choice. For 2027, the joint 22% bracket tops out at $218,250 and the 24% bracket at $416,650.

Because income is not certain until late in the year, many people convert in stages or in December, once the year's numbers are clear. Bracket tops for every filing status are on the tax planning reference.

The costs that do not show up in the bracket table

Conversion income raises AGI and MAGI, and a growing list of provisions key off those numbers. The real marginal cost of a conversion is often well above the bracket rate.

ProvisionHow a conversion affects it
Medicare premiums (IRMAA)Income-related surcharges on Part B and D, based on MAGI from two years earlier. Crossing a tier by $1 triggers the full surcharge for that tier.
Social Security taxationMore provisional income can make up to 85% of benefits taxable, adding a hidden layer of tax.
Net Investment Income TaxConversion income is not investment income, but it raises MAGI and can expose other investment income to the 3.8% NIIT.
Senior deduction (2025 to 2028)The $6,000-per-person deduction phases out at 6% of MAGI over $75,000 / $150,000.
SALT cap phase-downBetween about $505,000 and $606,000 of 2026 MAGI, each dollar of income also removes 30 cents of SALT deduction.
Capital gains rateConversion income can push qualified dividends and long-term gains out of the 0% rate.
Marketplace premium creditsHigher MAGI can reduce or eliminate premium tax credits for ACA coverage.
QBI deductionFor owners near the threshold, higher taxable income can begin limiting the 20% QBI deduction.

A conversion that looks like a 22% decision can turn out to be a 30%-plus decision once these are counted. Taxes on retirement income covers the Social Security and IRMAA calculations in detail. A full projection, not a bracket chart, is the only reliable way to see it.

The five-year rules

Two separate clocks apply, and they are often confused.

Conversion clock (penalty only). Each conversion starts its own five-year period. If you are under 59½ and withdraw converted principal within five years, the 10% penalty applies to the portion that was taxable when converted. Once you reach 59½, this clock stops mattering.

Roth IRA clock (tax on earnings). Earnings are tax-free only after you are 59½ and your first Roth IRA contribution or conversion was at least five tax years ago. This clock starts once, with your first Roth IRA, and covers all of them.

Roth IRA withdrawals come out in a set order: regular contributions first, then conversions oldest first, then earnings. That ordering is why contributions are always accessible and why conversion timing matters for anyone under 59½.

Roth conversions inside employer plans

Many 401(k) plans now allow in-plan Roth conversions, moving pre-tax plan money to the plan's Roth account. The tax treatment is the same. Small business plans now also allow Roth employer contributions and Roth SEP and SIMPLE accounts; see Roth options in small business retirement plans. Since 2024, Roth accounts in employer plans no longer have lifetime RMDs, which removed one of the old reasons to roll Roth 401(k) money to a Roth IRA.

Where the plan allows after-tax contributions beyond the regular deferral limit, converting those contributions promptly is the "mega backdoor Roth." Because the after-tax contributions already have basis, only the small amount of growth before conversion is taxable.

For business owners

Owners have more control over taxable income than most people, which makes conversion timing a real lever.

  • Pair conversions with deduction-heavy years. A year with bonus depreciation, a cost segregation study, a large retirement plan contribution, or a business loss is a natural conversion year.
  • Watch the QBI threshold. Conversion income counts toward taxable income for the QBI phase-in. An owner of a specified service business near the threshold could lose part of the 20% deduction; see how the QBI deduction is calculated.
  • Coordinate with entity changes. The year a business is sold, closed, or restructured often has unusual income, high or low, that changes the answer.

The short version

A Roth conversion trades tax now for tax-free money later. It wins when today's rate, including all the hidden costs tied to MAGI, is lower than the rate the money would otherwise face, for you, a surviving spouse, or heirs. Convert in partial amounts sized to a target bracket, pay the tax from outside the account, mind the five-year rules if you are under 59½, and remember there is no undo.

Rubric Financial models conversion amounts as part of year-end planning: a projection of this year's return with and without the conversion, including the Medicare, Social Security, and deduction effects, so the decision is made on the real marginal rate.

Sources

Figures are federal and current as of the date above. Tax law and inflation-adjusted amounts change; confirm current figures before acting.

Educational content, not tax, legal, investment, or accounting advice. Confirm the specifics with a CPA before acting. See our Terms.

Frequently asked questions

How is a Roth conversion taxed?

The pre-tax amount you convert from a traditional IRA or 401(k) to a Roth account is added to your ordinary income for the year and taxed at your marginal rate. There is no 10% early-withdrawal penalty on the conversion itself, regardless of age. Any after-tax basis in your traditional IRAs comes over tax-free, but the pro-rata rule spreads that basis across all of your traditional, SEP, and SIMPLE IRA balances.

When does a Roth conversion make sense?

When the rate you pay on the conversion today is lower than the rate the money would face when withdrawn later, by you or your heirs. That is most often true in low-income years: early retirement before Social Security and RMDs start, a business loss year, a sabbatical, or a year with large deductions. Conversions also help people who expect large required minimum distributions or want to leave tax-free accounts to heirs.

Is there an income limit for Roth conversions?

No. Anyone can convert any amount from a traditional IRA or eligible employer plan to a Roth, regardless of income. Income limits apply only to direct Roth IRA contributions, which is why higher earners use the backdoor Roth: a nondeductible traditional IRA contribution followed by a conversion.

Can I undo a Roth conversion?

No. Recharacterizing a conversion back to a traditional IRA has not been allowed since 2018. Once converted, the tax is owed even if the account value falls afterward. That is a reason to convert in stages, often late in the year when income is clearer, rather than all at once in January.

What is the five-year rule for Roth conversions?

Each conversion has its own five-year clock for the 10% penalty. If you are under 59½ and withdraw converted principal within five years of the conversion, the 10% penalty applies to the amount that was taxable when converted. After 59½ the conversion clock no longer matters for penalties. Separately, Roth earnings are tax-free only once you are 59½ and your first Roth IRA has been open five years.

About the author

Aparna Devalla, CPA, Partner, Tax & Accounting

Licensed CPA. Decades of experience in U.S. taxation, accounting, and banking. Leads the tax and accounting practice at Rubric Financial.

Want this handled instead of researched?

Tell us what your business looks like and a partner at Rubric Financial will scope the work: a fixed engagement cost, a monthly retainer, or hourly, whichever fits.

Get in touch