Skip to content
Rubric Financial

Payroll

Payroll Taxes Explained: Every Line on the Pay Stub and W-2, and What Employers Owe

A deep dive into payroll taxes: FICA, FUTA, SUTA, withholding, pre-tax deductions, W-2 boxes, deposit schedules, filings, penalties, and the true cost of an employee.

By 9 min readPublished

Payroll is where most small businesses first meet the tax system in real time. Every pay period, the business calculates several taxes, withholds some from the employee, adds others of its own, deposits them on a schedule that depends on its history, and reports them on quarterly and annual returns. Mistakes compound quickly, and the penalties are among the steepest in the code.

This guide is a reference for both sides of the paycheck. It explains each line on a pay stub, each box on a W-2, what employers owe on top of wages, how deposits and filings work, and how payroll taxes differ for owners. Current wage bases and rates are on our tax planning reference.

The taxes in one table

TaxEmployee paysEmployer paysWage base
Social Security (OASDI)6.2%6.2%$184,500 (2026); $192,300 (2027)
Medicare (HI)1.45%1.45%No limit
Additional Medicare0.9% on wages over $200,000NoneNo limit
Federal unemployment (FUTA)None6.0%, reduced to 0.6% by state creditFirst $7,000 per employee
State unemployment (SUTA)None in most statesRate set by state and experienceVaries by state
Federal income tax withholdingPer W-4 and IRS tablesNoneNot applicable
State and local income tax withholdingPer state and local rulesNoneNot applicable
State disability and paid leave programsVaries by stateVaries by stateVaries by state

Social Security and Medicare together are called FICA. The combined rate of 15.3% on wages up to the Social Security wage base is split evenly. Above the wage base, only the 2.9% Medicare tax continues, plus the employee's 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax above $200,000 of wages.

Reading a pay stub

A pay stub moves from gross pay to net pay in four steps.

1. Gross pay. Regular wages, overtime, bonuses, commissions, paid time off, and taxable fringe benefits such as a gift card or personal use of a company car.

2. Pre-tax deductions. Taken before some or all taxes are calculated:

DeductionReduces income tax wages?Reduces FICA wages?
Traditional 401(k), 403(b), 457 deferralsYesNo
Health, dental, vision premiums under a cafeteria (Section 125) planYesYes
HSA contributions through a cafeteria planYesYes
Health FSA and dependent care FSAYesYes
Qualified transportation and parking benefitsYesYes

The difference matters. A 401(k) deferral lowers income tax but not Social Security or Medicare. Cafeteria plan deductions lower both, which is why paying health premiums and HSA contributions through payroll saves an extra 7.65% compared with paying them yourself.

3. Taxes withheld. Federal income tax, Social Security, Medicare, state and local income tax, and any state disability or paid leave contributions.

4. Post-tax deductions. Taken after taxes: Roth 401(k) contributions, after-tax contributions, wage garnishments, union dues, and some insurance premiums.

Net pay is what remains.

Federal income tax withholding

Withholding is a prepayment of the employee's own income tax, not a separate tax. The Form W-4, redesigned in 2020, no longer uses allowances. Employees indicate filing status, multiple jobs or a working spouse, dependents, other income, deductions, and any extra amount to withhold. The employer applies IRS tables in Publication 15-T.

Supplemental wages, such as bonuses, commissions, and RSU vests, can be withheld at a flat 22%, or 37% for supplemental wages above $1 million in a year. Higher earners are often under-withheld as a result. See RSUs, NSOs, and ESPPs.

The Additional Medicare Tax is withheld on an individual's wages above $200,000 from one employer, regardless of filing status, so married couples and people with two jobs may owe more than was withheld.

The W-2, box by box

BoxWhat it shows
1Wages, tips, other compensation for federal income tax: gross pay minus pre-tax 401(k) and cafeteria plan deductions, plus taxable fringe benefits
2Federal income tax withheld
3Social Security wages: includes 401(k) deferrals, excludes cafeteria plan deductions, capped at the wage base
4Social Security tax withheld (6.2% of box 3)
5Medicare wages: like box 3 but with no cap
6Medicare tax withheld, including any Additional Medicare Tax
7Social Security tips
8Allocated tips
10Dependent care benefits
11Nonqualified deferred compensation distributions
12Coded items (see below)
13Checkboxes: statutory employee, retirement plan participant, third-party sick pay
14Other information the employer chooses to report, such as state disability contributions
15 to 20State and local wages and income tax

Common box 12 codes:

  • C: taxable cost of group-term life insurance over $50,000
  • D, E, G: traditional deferrals to a 401(k), 403(b), or governmental 457(b) plan
  • AA, BB, EE: Roth contributions to a 401(k), 403(b), or 457(b) plan
  • DD: cost of employer-sponsored health coverage, for information only, not taxable
  • W: employer and cafeteria plan contributions to an HSA
  • V: income from exercising nonqualified stock options (included in boxes 1, 3, and 5)

The box 13 "retirement plan" checkbox matters more than it looks. It marks the employee as covered by a workplace plan, which triggers the income limits on deducting traditional IRA contributions.

Starting with 2026 wages, employers also report qualified tips and qualified overtime compensation separately, so employees can claim the new deductions for tips and overtime under the 2025 tax law.

What employers owe on top of wages

FICA match. 7.65% of each employee's wages, up to the wage base for the Social Security part.

FUTA. 6.0% on the first $7,000 of each employee's wages, reduced by a credit of up to 5.4% for state unemployment taxes paid on time, for a net 0.6%, or $42 per employee per year. In "credit reduction" states that have unpaid federal loans for their unemployment funds, the credit is reduced and employers pay more.

SUTA. Each state sets its own wage base, which ranges from the federal $7,000 to well over $60,000, and assigns each employer a rate based on its industry and its history of former employees claiming benefits. New employers get a standard new-employer rate.

State and local programs. Depending on the state: disability insurance, paid family and medical leave, workforce training, transit taxes, and local income or payroll taxes. Some are paid by the employee, some by the employer, some shared.

The real cost of an employee. For a $60,000 salary, FICA adds $4,590, FUTA $42, and SUTA typically a few hundred dollars more, so payroll taxes alone add roughly 8% to 9% before any benefits, workers' compensation insurance, or payroll processing fees.

Deposits

Employers deposit withheld income tax and both shares of FICA electronically, generally through EFTPS. The schedule depends on the lookback period, the four quarters from July of two years earlier through June of the prior year:

Total tax in the lookback periodDeposit schedule
$50,000 or lessMonthly: by the 15th of the following month
More than $50,000Semiweekly: Wednesday or Friday after payday, depending on the payday
$100,000 or more accumulated on any dayNext business day, regardless of schedule
Less than $2,500 for the quarterCan be paid with the quarterly Form 941

New employers start as monthly depositors. FUTA is deposited quarterly once the accumulated liability exceeds $500. State taxes follow each state's own deposit rules.

Filings

FormWhatWhen
Form 941Quarterly federal payroll returnLast day of the month after each quarter
Form 944Annual alternative to 941 for very small employers, by IRS noticeJanuary 31
Form 940Annual FUTA returnJanuary 31
W-2 and W-3Wage statements to employees and the Social Security AdministrationJanuary 31
State withholding returnsMonthly or quarterly, plus an annual reconciliationVaries by state
State unemployment wage reportsQuarterlyVaries by state
Form 1099-NECPayments to contractors of $2,000 or more (from 2026 payments)January 31

When a date falls on a weekend or holiday, it moves to the next business day; the current dates are on our tax deadlines calendar.

Penalties

Failure to deposit: 2% if one to five days late, 5% if six to fifteen days late, 10% after that, and 15% if still unpaid ten days after an IRS notice demanding payment.

Failure to file and failure to pay penalties on Forms 941 and 940 apply on top, plus interest.

Trust fund recovery penalty. Withheld income tax and the employee's share of FICA belong to the government the moment they are withheld. Using them to cover rent or payroll in a cash crunch is the most expensive loan a business can take: the IRS can assess 100% of the unpaid trust fund taxes personally against any responsible person who willfully failed to pay them. Owners, officers, and bookkeepers with signing authority are all exposed. If payroll taxes fall behind, get help early; our IRS representation team handles these cases.

If a payroll tax balance cannot be paid in full, see IRS payment plans vs. an offer in compromise.

Owners and payroll

How an owner is paid depends on the entity:

  • Sole proprietors and partners are not employees and cannot be on payroll. They pay self-employment tax, the same 15.3% on net earnings, through estimated payments. See the self-employment tax guide and partnership income.
  • S-corp shareholders who work in the business must be on payroll with a reasonable salary. See S-corp reasonable compensation.
  • C-corp owner-employees are employees like any other.

Family members have special rules: children under 18 employed by a parent's sole proprietorship or parent-owned partnership are exempt from FICA, and spouses and parents are exempt from FUTA in some arrangements. See hiring family members.

Workers and contractors

Payroll taxes apply only to employees. Payments to independent contractors carry no withholding or employer taxes, but the classification is not a choice. It depends on control over the work, financial arrangements, and the relationship, and states often apply stricter tests. Misclassified workers create back payroll taxes, penalties, and state unemployment and wage claims. See 1099 vs. W-2.

Multi-state employees

Remote employees in other states usually require registration, withholding, and unemployment insurance in the state where they work, and sometimes in the employer's home state as well, depending on reciprocity agreements and convenience-of-the-employer rules. See multi-state payroll.

The short version

Employees pay 7.65% FICA plus income tax withholding; employers match the FICA and add FUTA, SUTA, and any state programs, roughly 8% to 9% on top of wages before benefits. Pre-tax deductions reduce different taxes, which is why W-2 boxes 1, 3, and 5 rarely match. Deposits run monthly or semiweekly based on the lookback period, returns are quarterly and annual, and unpaid trust fund taxes can become a personal liability. A payroll service handles the mechanics, but the classification, compensation, and deposit decisions remain the employer's.

Rubric Financial sets up and reviews payroll for clients, reconciles payroll filings to the books each quarter, and resolves notices and back payroll tax issues when they arise.

Sources

Figures are federal and current as of the date above. Tax law and inflation-adjusted amounts change; confirm current figures before acting.

Educational content, not tax, legal, investment, or accounting advice. Confirm the specifics with a CPA before acting. See our Terms.

Frequently asked questions

What payroll taxes does an employer pay?

Employers pay their own share of Social Security (6.2% of wages up to the wage base, $184,500 for 2026) and Medicare (1.45% of all wages), federal unemployment tax (FUTA, effectively 0.6% of the first $7,000 per employee in most states), and state unemployment insurance (SUTA), with rates and wage bases set by each state. Some states and localities add disability, paid family leave, workforce, or transit taxes.

What is the difference between FICA and federal income tax withholding?

FICA is Social Security and Medicare tax: a fixed percentage of wages paid by both the employee and the employer. Federal income tax withholding is a prepayment of the employee's own income tax, calculated from the W-4 and the IRS withholding tables. FICA is a final tax; income tax withholding is credited against the employee's actual tax on their return.

Why are the wages in W-2 boxes 1, 3, and 5 different?

Each box measures wages for a different tax. Box 1 is wages for income tax, which excludes pre-tax 401(k) deferrals and cafeteria plan deductions. Box 3 is Social Security wages, which include 401(k) deferrals but stop at the wage base. Box 5 is Medicare wages, which include 401(k) deferrals and have no cap. An employee with a 401(k) and high pay will see three different numbers.

When are payroll taxes due?

Withheld income tax and both shares of FICA are deposited electronically on a monthly or semiweekly schedule, determined by the employer's total tax liability in a lookback period. Liabilities of $100,000 or more on any day must be deposited by the next business day. Form 941 is filed quarterly, Form 940 annually, and W-2s are due to employees and the SSA by January 31.

What is the trust fund recovery penalty?

Withheld income tax and the employee share of FICA are held in trust for the government. If they are not paid over, the IRS can assess a penalty equal to 100% of the unpaid trust fund taxes personally against any responsible person who willfully failed to pay, typically owners, officers, and anyone with authority to sign checks. It survives the business, and it is not dischargeable in bankruptcy.

About the author

Nirmala Murugesan, CA, CPA, Partner, Accounting

Partner leading Rubric Financial's accounting practice. CA and CPA with 20+ years across U.S. GAAP, IFRS, and cross-border entity accounting in India and the U.S.

Want this handled instead of researched?

Tell us what your business looks like and a partner at Rubric Financial will scope the work: a fixed engagement cost, a monthly retainer, or hourly, whichever fits.

Get in touch